WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE WORD “NEW BUILDING”: URBAN ISSUES IN THE ODESA MEDIA
Abstract
Among the most important topics in the world of urban journalism is the topic of land ownership and housing affordability. In Ukraine, both in the media space and in scientific discourse, urban journalism is represented quite modestly. This makes relevant the goal of this work, which is to analyze the coverage of building development problems in Odesa by regional media in 2021. The last pre-war year was chosen deliberately since, with the beginning of a full-scale war, the agenda changed. The study used the thematic information search method, which was used to search for materials related, in one way or another, to building development issues in three online media (“Dumska”, “USI”, “Odeske Zhittya”) and two TV channels (“Suspilne Odesa”, “7 channel”) in 2021. Using published monitoring research data, we studied and described the context of the existence of media in Odesa in 2021. The study also used the discourse-analysis method, with which we tried to “find the hidden” and understand why such materials are published.
We managed to highlight authoritarian discourse when the author(s) declare the truth without offering alternatives. This is especially clearly seen in the example of media owned by businessmen or politicians, which promote the desired economic or political agenda. A good example is journalistic investigations that involve building developers, who are competitors of the media owner. Based on the interdiscursive nature of the text, we can note the presence of references to the hidden local-historical or, more precisely, the mythological discourse of "Old Odesa". This, in our opinion, is confirmed by the negative connotations of the word "new building", which are contained in all materials, except for commissioned ones: "new building" is something bad, something that disrupts the usual order of things.
Downloads
References
Odeske zhyttia. (2021, March 9). Adresa ye, a budynku nemaie: v Odesi demontuvaly budivliu, shcho obrushylasia na Torhovii (foto) [There is an address, but there is no house: In Odesa, a building that collapsed on Torhova Street was dismantled (photo)]. https://odessa-life.od.ua/news/adres-est-a-doma-net-v-odesse-demontirovali-obrushivsheesja-zdanie-na-torgovoj-foto
Instytut masovoi informatsii. (2021, March 5). Barometr svobody slova za liutyi 2021 roku (onovleno) [Freedom of speech barometer for February 2021 (updated)]. https://imi.org.ua/monitorings/barometr-svobody-slova-za-lyutyj-2021-roku-i37963
Suspilne Odesa. (2021, December 1). Budivnytstvo na Lidersovskomu bulvari, 7, de buly tenisni korty, prodovzhuietsia popry zaboronu sudu [Construction at 7 Lidersovsky Boulevard, where tennis courts used to be, continues despite a court ban] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/o5JDL366neQ?si=czMPefo6z14KkyaK
Dumska. (2021, June 5). “Budova” domovylasia z vidomoiu svitlotekhnichnoiu kompaniieiu Expolight pro novyi spilnyi proiekt v Odesi [“Budova” has agreed with the well-known lighting company Expolight on a new joint project in Odesa]. https://dumskaya.net/news/budova-dogovorilas-s-izvestnoy-svetotehnicheskoy-144825/ua/
Ukrainska sluzhba informatsii. (2021, December 16). “Budova” zabudovuie Kanatnu bez pohodzhennia z meriieiu [“Budova” is building up Kanatna Street without the consent of the city hall]. https://usionline.com/budova-zastraivaet-kanatnuju-bez-soglasovanija-s-mjeriej/
Verbovyi, R. M. (2015). Ghiperlokalni media yak ryznovyd ZMI: vyznachennia poniattia, funktsii, vydova kharakterystyka [Hyperlocal media as a type of media: Definition, functions, specific characteristics]. Derzhava ta rehiony. Seriia: Humanitarni nauky, 2(41), 73–77.
Suspilne Odesa. (2021, August 4). Vidnovlennia robit na terytorii drukarni Fesenka (Sohodni. Holovne) [Resumption of work on the territory of the Fesenko printing house (Today. Main)] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/0GhudI-d1UQ?si=0EhvEPYtDgizBDDD
Odeske zhyttia. (2021, March 22). V Odesi zabudovnyk znis budynok v unikalnomu styli (foto, video) [In Odesa, a building developer demolished a house in a unique style (photo, video)]. https://odessa-life.od.ua/news/v-odesse-zastrojshhik-snes-zdanie-postroennoe-v-unikalnom-stile-foto-video
Odeske zhyttia. (2021, April 12). V Odesi snosiat budivliu na Prokhorovskii (foto, video) [A building on Prokhorovska Street is being demolished in Odesa (photo, video)]. https://odessa-life.od.ua/news/v-odesse-snosjat-zdanie-na-prohorovskoj-foto-video
Ukrainska sluzhba informatsii. (2021, June 10). V Odesi obhovoriuvaly vypravlenyi istoryko-arkhitekturnyi plan: shcho zminylosia (foto) [In Odesa, the revised historical and architectural plan was discussed: What has changed (photo)]. https://usionline.com/v-odesse-obsuzhdali-ispravlennyj-istoriko-arhitekturnyj-plan-chto-izmenilos-foto/
Ukrainska sluzhba informatsii. (2021, December 31). V Odesi dorozhchaiut kvartyry: yakyi raion investory vvazhaiut pryvablyvym [Apartments are getting more expensive in Odesa: Which area do investors find attractive]. https://usionline.com/v-odesse-dorozhajut-kvartiry-kakoj-rajon-investory-schitajut-privlekatelnym
Deviatko, K. (2021, July 15). Urbanistyka – tse ne aktyvizm. Choho brakuie v media hromadskym orhanizatsiiam, yaki zainimaiutsia miskym seredovyshchem [Urbanism is not activism. What is missing in the media for civic organizations dealing with the urban environment]. Detektor Media. https://cs.detector.media/community/texts/184434/2021-07-15-urbanistyka-tse-ne-aktyvizm-chogo-brakuie-v-media-gromadskym-organizatsiyam-yaki-zaymayutsya-miskym-seredovyshchem/
Suspilne Odesa. (2021, May 11). Drukarnia Fesenka v Odesi: Mistsievi zaiavyly pro pidhotovku do znosu, zabudovnyk zaperechuie [Fesenko printing house in Odesa: Locals announced preparations for demolition, developer denies] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/qepXm205X2I?si=cNWJZdwYxJFkhpU7
Dumska. (2021, May 28). Zhakhlyvi budynky Odesy: pokhmuryi, vidsutnii na karti, spovzaiuchyi ta dity u “bermudskomu trykutnyku” (fotoreportazh, video) [Horrible houses in Odesa: Gloomy, missing on the map, creeping and children in the “Bermuda triangle” (photo report, video)]. https://dumskaya.net/news/samye-strashnye-doma-odessy-mrachnyy-otsutstvuyu-144069/ua/
Instytut demokratyi imeni Pylypa Orlyka. (2021, October 8). Zvit monitorynhu za veresень 2021 roku – Odeska oblast [Monitoring report for September 2021 – Odesa region]. https://idpo.org.ua/reports/4350-zvit-monitoringu-za-veresen-2021-roku-odeska-oblast.html
Suspilne Odesa. (2021, June 29). Znosyty tsentr dresuvannia sobak ne budut [The dog training center will not be demolished] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/s2dWt9o5rO4?si=y6PFvPsEX4_GD6pB
Ivanova, O., Moiseieva, O., & Steblyna, N. (2019). Misceva presa: posibnyk dlja ZMI. Jak reghionaljnym zhurnalistam pracjuvaty za chasiv novykh media ta kryzy demokratiji (O. Ivanova, Ed.). Kyiv: TOV «Biznespolihraf», 232 p.
Dumska. (2021, December 29). Kapitalnyj remont zaversheno: u sportkompleksi «Olimpijec» vidnovylysja trenuvannja [The major renovation has been completed: training has resumed at the «Olimpiyets» sports complex]. https://dumskaya.net/news/olimpietc_206-157585/ua/
kanal (@7kanalOdesa). (2021, November 4). Kivan Adnan uvijshov do rejtynghu 100 najbaghatshikh ukrajinciv [Kivan Adnan entered the ranking of the 100 richest Ukrainians] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/QsKdK4uRZXc?si=WaHVdhwyx2PhNTjP
Ukrajinsjka sluzhba informaciji. (2021, July 6). Koronavirus ne zavazhaje: v Odesi dorozhchaje nerukhomistj (infoghrafika) [Coronavirus does not hinder: real estate prices are rising in Odessa (infographics)]. https://usionline.com/koronavirus-ne-pomeha-v-odesse-dorozhaet-nedvizhimost-infografika/
Instytut masovoji informaciji. (2021, November 9). 47% materialiv pro koronavirus u reghionaljnykh onlajn-media — pro statystyku: doslidzhennja IMI [47% of coronavirus materials in regional online media are about statistics: IMI (Institute of Mass Information) study]. https://imi.org.ua/monitorings/47-materialiv-pro-koronavirus-v-regionalnyh-onlajn-media-pro-statystyku-doslidzhennya-imi-i42563
kanal (@7kanalOdesa). (2021, November 22). Meshkanci Bocharova, 55, vymaghajutj zupynyty budivnyctvo ZhK Sun City [Residents of Bocharova, 55, demand to stop the construction of the Sun City residential complex] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/54sQsQpmQX0?si=C1OeOU4lB_ooguzn
Suspiljne Odesa. (2021, April 12). Na Francuzjkomu buljvari vidbulasja akcija proty zabudovy pljazhu kolyshnjogho sanatoriju «rosija» [A protest against the development of the beach of the former sanatorium «russia» took place on French Boulevard] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/tZP4usHgni0?si=Tk4-cS9La_SN8weU
Nesteriak, Yu. M. (2014). Ghiperlokaljni media: perspektyvy dlja Ukrajiny [Hyperlocal media: prospects for Ukraine]. Naukovi zapysky instytutu zhurnalistyky, 56, 130–134.
Dumska. (2021, July 14). Pokynutyj dytsadok na selyshhi Kotovsjkogho zdaly v orendu: pryvatnyky obicjajutj zrobyty novyj ta uporjadkuvaty terytoriju [An abandoned kindergarten in the village of Kotovskoho has been leased: private owners promise to build a new one and improve the territory]. https://dumskaya.net/news/deputat-gorsoveta-ot-opzzh-zabrala-byvshiy-vedom-147252/ua/
kanal (@7kanalOdesa). (2021, July 27). Pro taki projekty baghato khto mrijav, ale tiljky KADORR Group navazhyvsja stvoryty spravzhnje «misto v misti» [Many people dreamed of such projects, but only KADORR Group dared to create a true «city within a city»] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/rgdwsc1eRak?si=TvfMC9Gf9lzG1SF6
kanal (@7kanalOdesa). (2021, March 2). Sprava proty zabudovy Mizhrejsovoji bazy — znovu krok nazad? [The case against the development of the Inter-Reach Base — another step backwards?] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/376YXyV8DlQ?si=GI_ka4ZCUS8KEGFI
Odesjke zhyttja. (2021, January 23). Strojploshhadka «Arkadyja» v Odesse: kak vыghljadyt «zamorozhennaja» strojka na Trasse zdorovjja? (foto) [«Arkadia» construction site in Odessa: what does the «frozen» construction site on the Health Route look like? (photo)]. https://odessa-life.od.ua/news/strojploshhadka-arkadija-v-odesse-kak-vygljadit-zamorozhennaja-strojka-na-trasse-zdorovja-foto
Ukrajinsjka sluzhba informaciji. (2021, December 21). Skandaljnyj zabudovnyk «vybyv» dozvil na torghovyj centr na Cheremushkakh [The scandalous building developer «knocked out» a permit for a shopping center in Cheremushki]. https://usionline.com/skandalnyj-zastrojshhik-vybil-razreshenie-na-torgovyj-centr-na-cheremushkah/
Temchenko, L. V. (2020). Urbanistychni mediapraktyky: jevropejsjkyj ta ukrajinsjkyj dosvid [Urban media practices: European and Ukrainian experience]. Communications and Communicative Technologies, 20, 80–87.
Ukrajinsjka sluzhba informaciji. (2021, July 26). U centri Odesy znesly fasad starovynnoji drukarni (foto, video) [The facade of an old printing house was demolished in the center of Odessa (photo, video)]. https://usionline.com/v-centre-odessy-snesli-fasad-starinnoj-tipografii-foto-video/
Instytut masovoji informaciji. (2017, April 20). Khto vplyvaje na odesjki ZMI? [Who influences the Odesa's media?]. https://imi.org.ua/articles/hto-vplivae-na-odeski-zmi-i162
kanal (@7kanalOdesa). (2021, November 9). Chym zaghrozhuje nove arkhitekturne zakonodavstvo [What are the threats posed by the new architectural legislation?] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/xwDfVcfE9Sk?si=AHCO268hIsKU0yKp
Suspiljne Odesa. (2021, February 10). Jurij Nikitin ta Ighor Fomichov pro sytuaciju navkolo Dachi Marazli (Sjoghodni.Gholovne) [Yuriy Nikitin and Igor Fomichev on the situation around the Marazli villa (Today.Main)] [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/NN6fNZW-ydg?si=1JjEYhOKMLJpA-qe
Prosvitnycjki materialy. (2022). Jak analiz dyskursu mozhe rozpiznaty zaghrozy nacionaljnij bezpeci [How discourse analysis can identify threats to national security]. Svoboda slova i nacionaljna bezpeka, Kyiv: UNCPD, 25 p.
Urban Journalism Network. (n.d.). Investigations — Urban Journalism Network. https://urbanjournalism.org/investigations/